Rusk is one of those sausage making ingredients that divides people. Some treat it as essential. Others think it's there to bulk out cheap sausages and dismiss it entirely. The truth, as usual, is somewhere in the middle - and which side you land on should depend on what you're making, not on principle.
I use rusk in some of my recipes and leave it out of others. Here's why.
What rusk actually does
Rusk is double-baked bread, ground down to a powder or coarse crumb. It contains no yeast, which matters, yeast would ferment in the mix and you'd end up with something odd. What rusk does have is a very high capacity for absorbing liquid. Depending on the grade, it can soak up three to four times its own weight in water.
In a sausage, that's doing two things for you. First, it's binding: it holds the fat and the meat protein together in a more cohesive mass, which means better structure in the casing and less tendency for the mix to crumble or separate. Second, it's retaining moisture: the water you've added to the mix gets locked into the rusk rather than pooling in the pan when you cook it. The result is a juicier sausage with more of the fat and flavour staying inside the meat rather than rendering out.
It also acts as a carrier for your seasoning, which is worth knowing. When you dissolve salt and spices in water before adding them to the mix, the rusk absorbs all of that seasoned liquid and distributes it evenly through the sausage. This is one of the reasons a rusk-based sausage can taste very well-seasoned even at modest spice levels.
When I use it
I use rusk when the recipe needs it to work, specifically when I'm using a higher proportion of liquid (beer, cider, stock, anything flavoured) and need something to hold that liquid in the mix, or when the fat ratio is on the lower side and I need a bit of extra help getting a good bind.
British-style sausages like Cumberland are a natural home for rusk. The traditional recipe calls for it, the texture benefits from it, and the percentage involved (typically 5–10% of the total mix weight) is nowhere near enough to water down the pork flavour. A 50g addition to a 900g batch is not filler,. it's functional.
I also reach for it when I want a slightly lighter, softer texture. Rusk opens the mix up a little. It's the difference between a dense, firm sausage and something with a bit more give to it. Whether that's what you want depends on the recipe.
When I leave it out
When I want the pork to really dominate, I drop the rusk. A coarsely minced pork shoulder with a good fat content - around 20–25% - will bind perfectly well without it, as long as you mix thoroughly enough to develop the protein and you've got the temperature right throughout. Cold meat mixes faster and binds better. If your mix is tacky and holds together when you press it, you don't necessarily need rusk to make it work.
Recipes like boerewors I've deliberately left rusk-free. It's a coarser, more rustic sausage where the whole point is that you're tasting the beef and the coriander, not a softer, moister background texture. The same logic applies to anything where the meat is the star and you want maximum intensity.
What to use if you haven't got proper rusk
Proper butcher's rusk is the best option, it's ground consistently, absorbs well, and has a neutral flavour. But if you haven't got it, I use what's in the cupboard. Dried breadcrumbs work. Panko works, though it's coarser and absorbs a bit differently, so soak it in your liquid for a couple of minutes before adding to the mix rather than throwing it in dry. Regular stale bread, blitzed and dried out, works too.
The one thing I wouldn't do is use fresh breadcrumbs, too much residual moisture, which makes it very hard to predict how the mix is going to behave.
The short version
Rusk isn't cheating and it isn't there to pad out cheap sausages. It's a functional ingredient with a specific job - water retention and bind. Use it when that job needs doing. Leave it out when you want the meat to speak for itself and your fat ratio and technique will carry it. And if you're out of proper rusk, breadcrumbs are fine... just adjust accordingly.